There is a lot of misinformation, myths and hype regarding foundation repair methods. We at Granite Foundation Repair hope to clear that up for you. Some foundation repair contractors will recommend steel pier foundation repair, others mudjacking, others concrete piers…how do you know what is best?
Keep in mind that this foundation repair information pertains exclusively to foundation repair situations found in the Dallas Ft Worth (DFW) area.
Different soils and foundation types demand different repair methods. There is no single magic bullet for repairs across all of America.
We will look at:
- The best foundation repair system, comparison of steel and pressed concrete piers or piles
- Mud jacking pros and cons
- Why void filling under a slab is not always good
- How straightly installed are steel piers and concrete pilings
- Why concrete piers will rust
Myth 1) The best foundation repair system is a “self testing system” driven to refusal. Steel foundation repair systems are typically driven to a rock strata, while pressed piling systems are more often, “driven to refusal”. Refusal means that you cannot push the pier system downward any deeper. That does not mean that the underpinning system has achieved adequate depth to avoid the negative effects of seasonal moisture variation.
In the case of pressed or pre-cast concrete pilings or piers, refusal typically means the concrete piling system has been pushed to compressed clay. Pressed concrete pilings seldom are driven deeper than 15 feet, and in many areas achieve refusal at depths of 6-10 feet. Concrete piling depth is extremely dependent upon soil moisture content. For straight steel, refusal means that the steel has been driven to shale or bedrock.
Here are actual comparisons of piling depths obtained during two foundation repairs. In each case, steel piers were proven to provide better depth than pressed concrete pilings, with much less stress on the house.
|Steel Pier||Pressed Concrete Piling|
|Site 1||30 feet (to refusal)||15 feet (to refusal)|
|Site 2||18 feet (to refusal)||8 feet (to refusal)|
Myth 2) Mud jacking is a good low cost way to lift a foundation. In some cases mud jacking may be one element of the overall foundation repair solution. However, a long lasting foundation repair solution almost always requires the installation of piers or pilings driven to strong load bearing strata.
Myth 3 ) The void under a slab foundation should always be filled after the house has been lifted. Foundation repair companies will seldom fill the void, to allow for normal soil expansion during wet periods. When a void is filled in an area where the clay is not maximally expanded, adding water to the expansive clay may force the void fill material up through the floor. Expansive wet clay soil is stronger than the typical 4-5 inch thick slab foundation.
Myth 4) Steel piers and pressed pilings can be installed crooked, leaving the house unstable. During the pile driving process, the soil forms a rigid wall, constraining each section of pipe or concrete to follow the next straight down. Neither steel or concrete is driven in a crooked manner by a competent installation team. Just ask your engineer.
Myth 5) Concrete piers are best because they will not rust. Contractors who exclusively promote concrete foundation leveling systems want you to think that concrete is superior because steel piers will rust. If steel rusting underground were a problem, then every concrete system would have a problem:
At the top of each concrete pier system there is a stack of ¼ inch thick steel shims. The steel shims are a fundamental part of each concrete pier house leveling and foundation repair.
Truth is that if rusting steel were a problem, it would be most evident in the poured concrete or pressed concrete piling foundation repair systems. When foundation repair systems are left undisturbed underground, a thin protective layer of rust forms on the steel shims, as well as on steel pier systems.
Steel pier systems are predominantly made up of high carbon steel which is less susceptible to the effects of oxygen and water on steel.
Recent changes in many Dallas, Fort Worth, Arlington, Grand Prairie, Plano, Garland and other local DFW municipalities’ building codes mandate steel shims rather than wood shims for pier and beam houses.
For no-obligation evaluation of your foundation, email now or call 972-412-2171 or 817.870.1381